Battlestar Galactica Reimagined Circa 2003

After the original Battlestar Galactica TV show ended its run in the late ’70s there have been numerous attempts to revive it. Some included efforts by Bryan Singer and Richard Hatch, the star of the original TV show. But none were successful until Syfy greenlit a remake instead of a sequel to the orignal show, which aired as a two-part mini-series on the cable channel beginning on December 8, 2003.

Distinctly darker and more grounded than the original TV show, the new Battlestar Galactica quickly won acclaim from critics and fans, even those who were skeptical over the changes made to the concept. The mini-series was so successful that Syfy quickly ordered a series, which began airing later in 2004.

The basic premise of the new Battlestar Galactica was similar to the original TV show. In a distant part of the galaxy, a fragile truce between humans and a cybernetic race called the Cylons is shattered when the Cylons launch a surprise attack that destroys the human civilization. The few remaining human survivors set off in a ragtag fleet led by the last remaining battlestar warship called Galactica to find refuge in the lost human colony world known as Earth.

Whereas the original Battlestar Galactica clearly followed the spirit of Star Wars with an emphasis on starship battles and admittedly cheesy scripts, this version was edgier and grittier. It was clear that this 2003 version of Battlestar Galactica was influenced by 9/11. This turned off some fans of the original Battlestar Galactica who desired a more innocent rendition, but the reimagining drew in many more fans to take their place. They welcomed the moral dilemmas and flawed characters that were the main feature of the mini-series as the aftermath of war and its impact on humanity was fleshed out. The show was so grounded that even though these humans lived in a distant part of the galaxy they wore the same kind of clothes we wear today including business suits. They spoke like normal people, too with the exception that the F word was replaced by “frak” to get around censors, although this made up curse word was used too often and unrealistically in normal conversations.

Another way Battlestar Galactica stood apart from the original was with its exceptional acting. Starting from acclaimed and well known actors like Edward James Olmos and Mary McDonnell to relative newcomers like Jamie Bamber, Katee Sackhoff and James Callis, they infused their roles with needed gravitas which engaged the audience. Unlike the original which focused on the adventurous exploits of Captain Apollo and his buddy wingman Starbuck, the clear leads in the remake were Olmos’ William Adama and McDonnell’s President Laura Roslin. Both characters were unexpectedly thrust into leadership roles for the desperate remains of humanity looking for any kind of guidance and hope. Even with the compelling and mature leads, the remake was more of an ensemble piece, as it prominently featured other important characters like Adama’s son Apollo (Bamber) and his best friend, Starbuck (Sachhoff in a role that was orignally portrayed by a man).

Adding to the drama was that the Cylons were hunting down the last remnants of humanity. One of these survivors was Dr. Gaius Baltar (Callis), who unwittingly helped the Cylons destroy human civilization and grapples with his guilt as he is taunted and seduced by an imaginary Cylon called Number Six (Tricia Helfer). She is part of a new race of Cylons that evolved to look and act like humans and were able to infiltrate human society. This new wrinkle with the Cylons added an intriguing twist and put a face to the enemy, which in the original show were just robots without any personality. This development also introduced an element of paranoia as the humans were no longer sure if the enemy was hiding in plain sight among them ready to commit acts of sabotage and terrorism.

The success of Battlestar Galactica revitalized interest in the IP and led to a TV series that ran for four seasons, a spinoff series called Caprica and there are reports of a new version to be produced. Some of the best sci-fi episodes of any TV show were part of the TV show’s lineup as it further developed the plot lines and characters introduced in the mini-series. This would not have been possible if the Battlestar Galactica 2003 mini-series failed to find an audience and it is why it should be praised for its accomplishments twenty years later.

8 comments on “Battlestar Galactica Reimagined Circa 2003

  1. I remember hearing about this show when it first came out, but never watched it during its original release on TV. A friend of mine told me about it and I back the first season on DVD. I was immediately hooked and bought the rest of the series. It was actually really good. Some episodes were pointless fillers (like all series have), but the core episodes were terrific. Best one (in my opinion) was “Unfinished Business”. Didn’t progress the plot of the series, but great character development from the main cast.

    • The show was not perfect but was very well done and boasted some of the best sci-fi episodes ever done for a TV show. The best arc done was the New Caprica storyline and it kind of meandered after that but it was still really good.

    • That’s hard to say and is based on your preference. The original is a fun space opera though kind of limited with overused stock footage of space battles. The second half of its run is when it takes off.

      The remake is more grounded, grittier and relatable. The FX are great as is the acting and some storyline. It does meander for a bit and is a bit full of itself. So both have pros and cons. But if push came to shove for me the original just barely edges the remake purely for nostalgic reasons.

  2. With all the energy throughout the 90s put into revitalizing the Star Trek universe, it was naturally interesting enough to see how well others from our space age genre could be revived thanks to the inspirations behind them. From this century’s Battlestar Galactica to the very recent Lost In Space and now the new Babylon 5, the challenges for what the modern era can somehow build upon can either be great improvements or great reasons for nostalgically preferring the original versions. I appreciated the more profound areas that the new BSG was clearly aiming for. Especially with the casting of Edward James Olmos, given his famous mark in gritty SF thanks to playing Gaff in Blade Runner. Although I didn’t follow this series, some clips in my YouTube browsing were a very good sign of how it was helping to change a great deal for SF TV dramas. Thank you for your review.

    • Thanks, glad you liked the post. These remakes can be hit or miss and are a symptom of how Hollywood has run out of ideas and wants to play it safe with recognizable IP. OTH these remakes like BSG help renew interest with the original source material or can be enjoyed for the first time by those who never saw them before.

  3. The rebooted Battlestar Galactica is gem of a show that totally reinvigorated the genre. It wasn’t always an easy watch, there were some powerful stories and themes at play in it, but it totally brought a new spin to BG. Been a while since I’ve seen it, think its well overdue a rewatch.

    • The remake certainly warrants a rewatch especially if the newly announced series actually gets made. The new show also will have a challenge in meeting the creative heights of the early 2000s remake.

Leave a comment