Star Trek: Strange New Worlds started off strong when it began streaming years ago and had a competent second season that continued with its episodic nature that reminded many Trek fans of the old days of Star Trek shows that didn’t bother with complicated season-long storylines. However, Star Trek: Strange New Worlds began to falter in its third season with lackluster episodes and it was hoped that with its just-concluded fourth season that the show would course correct itself. Unfortunately that was not to be. The fourth season is a lot better than the third one, but two glaring issues have marred the season for Star Trek: Strange New Worlds–an overreliance on gimmick stories and too many appearances by James T. Kirk.
This is regrettable because the fourth season has many merits such as the acting, the production values (Star Trek has never looked better on the TV screens), and some episodes were true standouts. In fact, its premiere episode “Valles Marineris” was not only the best episode of the season but one of the best Star Trek episodes ever with a time travel yarn that reveals how pivotal the Enterprise and its crew were to our history. So imagine how disappointing it is to then be inundated with a bunch of gimmick episodes like the one where the Enterprise crew, except Spock, are turned into puppets (“Level-Five Transporter Incident”) or the crew end up in a reality that resembles a soap opera (“Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass”). Even the better received episodes can be seen as gimmick episodes. For example, “Valles Marineris” is seen as a knock-off of Jurassic Park, while “Orders of Magnitude” was a thinly veiled remake of Crimson Tide. But those are just surface-level similarities. Also keep in mind that the series will end with a short fifth season of just six episodes. It just makes one wonder why are the producers and scriptwriters wasting time with these gimmick episodes?
Defenders of these gimmick episodes will point out that Star Trek has done such episodes before, even in the original series (TOS) had them like “A Piece of the Action” or “Patterns of Force”, but the difference is that TOS and other older Star Trek TV shows had longer episode runs in their seasons, and their gimmick episodes were spread out and didn’t overtake the regular, more serious episodes. Nowadays, Star Trek TV shows only have about ten-episode runs per season. That is not a lot of episodes and given the precious few episodes and long waits between seasons, the producers should only allow one to two gimmick or comedic episodes per season. In the fourth season, instead of exploring new planets or meeting new alien races, the Enterprise crew were turned into puppets or ran around intoxicated in a pleasure planet (“Human Best Friend”) which ended being a pedestrian attempt at comedy, or acted out fantasy roles without even bothering to scientifically explain the presence of magic (“Once La’An A Time”). What made these gimmicks so frustrating was that there were attempts to tell compelling character studies. For instance, the puppet episode supposedly explains why Spock became more logical by the time TOS came along, while the soap opera episode revealed that Captain Pike is undergoing severe grief and has to confront it. The problem is that these interesting sub plots are shoehorned into the main story and were not fully developed.
Speaking of Captain Pike, the premise of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds was to showcase his time as the captain of the Enterprise, as well as the crew during that time period. At the end of the first season James T. Kirk was introduced in the episode “A Quality of Mercy” in an alternate reality and played by Paul Wesley, and he has appeared in subsequent seasons, but by the fourth season, he has supplanted Pike as the main character. Strange New Worlds is supposed to focus on Pike and his crew as an ensemble piece like most Star Trek shows, but it seems like in every other episode of the fourth season, some reason is concocted to have Kirk on the Enterprise. Sometimes the appearances were organic other times they did not make sense. For instance, in one episode Kirk goes to the ship to get a medical exam. Really? His own ship doesn’t have medical facilities? Or in one episode, he just happens to be on the same pleasure planet that the Enterprise crew visit. That’s too convenient. All in all, Kirk appeared in five episodes this season, which is half of the season. That is way too many episodes to devote to him and what is worst is that those appearances were not necessary. Take “Orders of Magnitude” a rogue Starfleet admiral commandeers the Enterprise and assigned Kirk to be the first officer who is forced to confront the admiral when the superior officer orders the crew to decimate a planet’s population. Why did this have to be Kirk? Pike could have easily filled in this role and could have fed into a narrative that he was becoming disillusioned with his career or the incident could have been why he was promoted later on.
What makes the many appearances of James Kirk so problematic has to do with the casting of Wesley. Sadly, he is not William Shatner. True, trying to fill in the shoes of the original actor to play the iconic Kirk is very difficult, but Shatner’s Kirk had a sense of bravado and charm that is not evident with Wesley’s version of Kirk. Sure, at this point in time, Wesley’s Kirk has not grown into the role yet and there have been instances where he showed hints of becoming Shatner’s Kirk, but he just lacks the sense of authority and charisma that the original Kirk had. On the other hand, Wesley’s portrayal of Kirk is more faithful and authentic than Chris Pine’s in the rebooted Star Trek films; at least he does not come off as a spoiled frat boy which is how Pine’s Kirk seems. Still, he appeared too many times and took away any desire to see more of him in the failed series proposal of Star Trek: Year One. Perhaps it is for the best. Given the way continuity has been shredded with the recent Star Treks, one can only imagine how a series set around the time of TOS would be received. The best we will get were the glimpses of Kirk’s command in the season finale “Tomorrow’s Enterprise”, an episode that could have been a great time travel episode but was undone by poor writing. At least in this instance Kirk’s appearance makes sense and Wesley’s performance is not why the episode failed.
The core issue with the fourth season of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds is not just the abundance of gimmick episodes and James T. Kirk. It is with the scripts. The overreliance on gimmick scripts is a symptom of lackluster writing. It seems as if the writers grew bored with the basic premise of Star Trek and decided to write in so-called tributes to other genres. This is unforgiveable given that the show is coming to a conclusion and tepid efforts were made to wrap up character arcs, and the fact there are precious few episodes left. One should be hopeful that in the fifth and final season the writers would step up and give us some truly memorable Trek episodes and go out on a high. But that is doubtful.
