Requiem For A Dark Knight

ben-affleck-as-batman
The status of Ben Affleck’s role in the upcoming Batman film directed by Matt Reeves has been a source of both interest and mystery ever since Affleck left that film’s role as director two years ago. This mystery was finally solved a few days ago with the article on deadline.com that detailed a release date for the film titled The Batman, which will come to theaters on June 25th, 2021 with a new actor to be cast in the role. This was seemingly confirmed by Affleck himself, who retweeted the article on his Twitter account. This news has brought a reaction from fans that of sadness and regret since he will no longer be playing a role that he has owned since his debut in 2016’s Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice. The initial announcement of his casting as Batman was met with some skepticism at first, but after the first trailer for the movie, with the image of Bruce Wayne staring at his Batman outfit, consumed with rage, fans were convinced of his ability to play the dual role of playboy millionaire and costumed vigilante, obsessed with stopping what he saw as the ultimate threat in Superman. His excellent performance in the somewhat divisive film cemented his legacy as the definitive live-action Batman. His brief, but well received, cameo in Suicide Squad further excited fans. His last full time appearance as the Caped Crusader in Justice League in 2017 was met with mixed results since he seemed somewhat disinterested. Possibly this was due to reshoots by Joss Whedon and rewrites to the story that changed what the original director Zack Snyder had planned. But, overall, I thought his performance was still a great interpretation of a transformed Bruce Wayne who was trying to live up to Superman’s example and not let his sacrifice in Batman v Superman go in vain. 
I do wish that Ben Affleck was given another opportunity to play the role. However, due to the reaction to both Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice and Justice League, as well as his own personal problems with alcoholism and a high profile divorce, this led to his wavering on whether or not to continue the role. Also complicating things was the fact that Matt Reeves wants to tell a story of a younger Batman that takes place maybe 10-15 years before the events of Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice. There were some rumors that Affleck might play the older version of Batman at the start and end of the movie, but this seems to have been rejected by Reeves.  His vision of a noir-driven detective film does sound interesting and unique, but it would have been great to see Affleck in this type of film as well, since his previous movies as Batman focused on his fighting abilities and strengths. As for who will replace him, there are, of course, lots of rumors on that as well. One is Armie Hammer, who would be a good replacement. Hammer has been rumored to be up for the part of Hal Jordan in the upcoming Green Lantern Corps film, but that movie is still several years away with Geoff Johns writing a new script for it. Another one rumored is Aaron Taylor-Johnson from 2014’s Godzilla and 2010’s Kick-Ass. Whoever is picked should not be so young as to look more like Robin than Batman. Even though Reeves is supposedly looking for an actor in the range of 25-30, this Batman should already be an experienced crime fighter. Christoper Nolan’s Batman Begins in 2005 already told the story of the Caped Crusader first starting out. Another origin story is not needed. Whoever is cast needs to have the same presence that Affleck had and be able to show that he will eventually become the force that dominated Gotham’s underworld in Batman v Superman.
If there is ever another Justice League movie or another DCEU film that takes place in present day, one hopes that Affleck will be called on to don the cape again, but that is unknown at this point. If he never plays the role again, his legacy is still cemented in comic movie lore as arguably the most accurate Bruce Wayne and Batman to show up on the big screen. Every role is eventually recast at some point. Look at how many actors have played the role of James Bond over the years. Batman is no exception. The character is over 75 years old and will go on no matter who plays him, so while it’s sad that Ben Affleck is leaving, any hysteria over this is not really necessary. I just hope that whoever takes the torch from him is able to live up to the standard he set and helps Matt Reeves make another great Batman movie.
C.S. Link

6 comments on “Requiem For A Dark Knight

  1. A great tribute to Ben Affleck as Batman who quickly put to rest any trepidation with his powerful portrayal in BvS. Like yourself I had no provlem with his performance in Justice League and it felt like a natural progression from the events of the previous film.

    It’s a shame he’s now officially departed the role but it’s not as if, despite the odd glimmer of hope, we weren’t expecting it.

    I’m now excited to see how The Batman develops, I have total faith in Matt Reeves as a storyteller and filmmaker after what he brought to Planet of the Apes and I’m sure the right actor will be cast to take the Dark Knight Detective forward.

    • Totally agree with you here. It is hard to believe how many of us scoffed at the news when Affleck was first announced as Batman. But then he won us over so completely with his performance in BvS.

      It’s interesting to note that Josh Brolin was a strong contender for the role at one time. One can only wonder how that would’ve turned out!

      Surely, Reeves will find a suitable replacement and at least Affleck won’t suffer the derision that George Clooney got for his solo outing. 😀

  2. While I was no fan of BvS, I didn’t mind Justice League, and I thought Ben Affleck’s cameo in Suicide Squad was good as well. I do think its a shame Ben Affleck won’t get the chance to star in a solo Batman film now though, it would’ve been great to see what he’d do with the role, sadly that’s not to be now. It will certainly be interesting to see how the new Batman movie develops and who takes over the role of the Dark Knight next.

    • It would be terrific if Affleck could return to the role sometime later on in a proper, solo Batman film.

      If only elements of The Dark Knight Returns had not been used in BvS, then an actual adaptation of that graphic novel starring Affleck could be a viable option.

      • I agree, if they hadn’t used Dark Knight Returns as the basis for BvS, it would’ve worked much better and given Affleck a better chance to do something really impressive with the role as Batman.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s