Spider-Man: Brand New Day Presents The Most Authentic Version Of Spider-Man Yet

Reeling from recent box office disappointments Marvel Studios brought out its big guns for the newest film set in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) with the latest Spider-Man film. After slightly over a year since we’ve had an MCU film, Spider-Man: Brand New Day is a return to form for Marvel Comics’ most popular superhero as the latest MCU Spider-Man film presents the character at his most authentic yet.

A common complaint about the MCU version of Spider-Man was that he was basically Iron Man, Jr. and his fawning over Iron Man, over-reliance on MCU references, and outer space trips did not help. This was done to differentiate the character from past versions of cinematic Spider-Men, but now that the character became his own independent solo character by the end of the last film, he was returned to the more grounded comic-book accurate version fans have come to love. Spider-Man/Peter Parker (Tom Holland) is now a lonely young man who scrapes by in a frugal existence and is solely devoted to fighting crime in New York City as your friendly neighborhood Spider-Man.

When Spider-Man: No Way Home, the last Spider-Man film, ended, a magic spell was cast that made the whole world, including his girlfriend MJ Watson (Zendaya) and his best friend Ned Leeds (Jacob Batalon),, forget that Peter Parker existed. This film deals with the consequences of that spell as Peter lives a solitary life in a decrepid rented attic working on upgrading his suit and fighting crime. An opening montage shows how for the past four years since No Way Home ended, Peter kept himself busy fighting assorted supervillains and helping the New York City police. In his down time, he monitors Ned’s social media feeds to keep track of him and MJ. During one incident involving a break-in at the federal detention center for the Department of Damage Control (DODC), Spider-Man goes to help the federal guards and encounters an unseen person (Sadie Sink) who can telepathically possess people, except him. His conflict with the person draws the attention of Frank Castle (Jon Bernthal), an uneasy ally of Spider-Man who is the murderous vigilante called the Punisher. Unlike Spidey, Castle has no inhibition in trying to kill the telepath while Spider-Man wants to try to capture her for the DODC.

As he grapples with this new enemy Peter learns that he is starting to evolve physically; he is able to shoot organic webbing, his senses become overwhelming enhanced to the point they nearly debilate him, and his strength and agility increase. Alarmed by his development, Peter seeks out Dr. Bruce Banner (Mark Ruffalo) for advice. Banner who is also the Hulk, has been able to keep his monstrous personna under control through an inhibitor that Peter hopes to duplicate to dampen his increased powers. At the same time, his intense loneliness drives him to eventually seek out MJ and Ned and try to find some way to reconnect with them. Naturally, all these plot lines converge with disastrous results as Peter has to find a way to come to grips with his emotional and physicaly plight while trying to stop the telepath.

Spider-Man: Brand New Day was directed by Destin Daniel Cretton, the same person who helmed Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings and Wonder Man. Unlike the previous director, Cretton brings much needed energy to Spider-Man’s antics which now feels kinetic and literally off the wall. The camera never stops moving and presenting dynamic and colorful scenes that are filmed off kilter, which could be disorienting but better captures the mind set of our favorite wall crawler. Needless to say, it is the best filmed Spider-Man film. The fight scenes and the visceral web swinging are easily the best ever shown in a Spider-Man film. It felt as if you were there with him as he swung through the City that Never Sleeps. BTW, the look and feel of New York City feels authentic and adds to the grounded and frentic nature of the film. There are also many beautifully set up scenes that capture iconic images and covers from the Spider-Man comics that fit in well with the tone of the film and flows perfectly.

But what made the film so special was its emphasis on the emotional core of Spider-Man and the telepath who are both injured and fragile souls that are at odds with the outside world. The narrative is fast paced and holds your attention despite the film’s length.

Spider-Man fits in perfectly with the MCU as its references and characters don’t feel in-your-face unlike some of the previous MCU Spider-Man films. This time, we get a street level connection to the former Netflix Marvel TV shows, especially Daredevil and Daredevil: Born Again (and no despite our hopes Daredevil does not appear in the film), in the form of the Punisher. Both Holland and Bernthal have great chemistry together as their two characters oddly complement each other. Much of the banter and emotions they share are some of the best moments in the film and will bring a smile to your face.

All the actors were at the top of their game in the film. Tom Holland himself turns in his best performance as Peter/Spider-Man who is now more mature and downbeat but is still trying to find a way to connect in the world. The moments Holland has with Zendaya were so involving and feel so genuinely human, it probably helped that the two actors are married in real life! You can just empathize with Peter as he is anguished to know that MJ does not remember him or the love they once shared. It was very haunting and you can sense the distress coming off Peter in those moments.

Of course the film is not perfect. There are a lot of narratives going on which could have collapsed the film if not for Cretton’s steady hand and smart editing. Also, the storyline with the telepath sometimes takes away from the plight of Spider-Man and, without giving anything away, could be seen as just a way to set up other MCU projects, but it was very well done and engaging.

It’s hard to say where Spider-Man: Brand New Day would rank among the other Spider-Man films. It is arguably the best of the MCU Spider-Man films and rivals the early Sam Raimi films, though Spider-Man 2 is still the GOAT. Marvel Studios would be wise to retain Cretton for future Spider-Man films since he is a perfect fit for the superhero. Now on to Avengers: Doomsday!

José Soto